The Lee Silverman Voice Training (LSVT) “Loud” program is a popular method used by speech/language clinicians to improve vocal volume and clarity in people with Parkinson’s disease. I’ve never been all that enthusiastic about it because there is no literature demonstrating superiority to traditional forms of speech therapy for PD. For another thing, I’m a little suspicious of its proprietary financial model, where a clinician pays anywhere from $300 (for a student) to $990 (for a professional) for a two-day course that yields a certificate permitting them to advertise that they offer LSVT. The courses and certificates are available only from LSVT Global, Inc.
Potential evils of capitalism aside, it’s good to see someone finally trying to help the dysarthria of PSP. Our heroes are a group in Rome headed by the well-regarded movement disorders authority Fabrizio Stocchi, MD PhD. The paper‘s first author is Patrizio Sale, MD PhD. a neuro-rehabilitation specialist. The work appeared in the European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine.
The study compared the benefit of LSVT Loud in 16 patients with PSP to the same four-week course of treatment in 23 patients with PD. Both groups did improve in most of the measures applied. Probably the most positive result was in the reading task, where the maximum volume for the patients with PSP improved from an average of 82.5 dB to an average of 87.5 dB. Somewhat more modest benefits accrued for nonverbal phonation and for non-reading speech.
Unfortunately, there were no control patients receiving sham treatment, traditional treatment or no treatment. We don’t know if the improvement will long persist, but the literature suggests that it does so in PD. Equally important is that the study did not evaluate articulation — only volume. Furthermore, the study was quite small, inviting flukey results. Clearly, more work is needed, but for now, I’ll try sending some of my patients with PSP and hypophonia (low vocal volume) for LSVT. I’ll let you know what happens.